Why Windows 10 Sucks

TechLady

Well-Known Member
Reaction score
3,174
Location
CA
Some interesting reading...

https://itvision.altervista.org/why-windows-10-sucks.html

It highlights some of the things about it that bothers me most:

"You've got no real control over crucial features of the OS -
  • Windows 10 will have no service packs which means it will always be a work in progress and you are a perpetual beta tester.
  • Forced updates you cannot opt out of (and Microsoft have borked quite a lot of them recently so prepare to see your Windows die after installing a new portion of updates - actually Microsoft has already borked one update, read horror stories about KB3081424). In December 2016 Chris Capossela, chief marketing officer at Microsoft, admitted that the company had went too far with the way Windows updates are distributed.
  • Safe Mode has become impossible to access unless you've booted into ... the running OS which totally defeats its purpose. Also Safe Mode is hidden behind almost a dozen of steps vs. a single F8 key press on boot in every Windows version from 95 to 7.
  • Windows 10 anniversary update makes it very difficult (read impossible for average users) to disable Cortana.
  • Windows 10 violates the basic networking principles: it ignores the hosts files, the DNS protocol and firewall rules and sends telemetry data regardless."
 
Did Microsoft fire everyone in their QA/QC department?

My guess is they fired the entire windows team: developers, managers and QA. In their place they hired a bunch of managers who are good at meeting deadlines regardless of the quality of the product and developers who can deliver the infamous two out of three: fast and cheap. Oh and they didn't bother hiring new QA staff, that's our job now right?

Make sure you also read an article about the cluster**** called Anniversary Update - there are numerous reports that the installer kills all the partitions which Windows doesn't know about (Linux users beware).

Didn't know about this one...
 
  • Like
Reactions: GTP
Welcome to Continuous Delivery. The problem is that Windows is such a monstrous piece of software that introducing automated testing at this point is bound to be missing things, and they have no way to quickly fix a bug if the bug crashes the computer or network services, etc. Some webapps are doing thousands of deployments a day and we don't notice anything, but applying the model to an OS is quite a task.
 
Some interesting reading...

https://itvision.altervista.org/why-windows-10-sucks.html

It highlights some of the things about it that bothers me most:

"You've got no real control over crucial features of the OS -
  • Windows 10 will have no service packs which means it will always be a work in progress and you are a perpetual beta tester.
  • Forced updates you cannot opt out of (and Microsoft have borked quite a lot of them recently so prepare to see your Windows die after installing a new portion of updates - actually Microsoft has already borked one update, read horror stories about KB3081424). In December 2016 Chris Capossela, chief marketing officer at Microsoft, admitted that the company had went too far with the way Windows updates are distributed.
  • Safe Mode has become impossible to access unless you've booted into ... the running OS which totally defeats its purpose. Also Safe Mode is hidden behind almost a dozen of steps vs. a single F8 key press on boot in every Windows version from 95 to 7.
  • Windows 10 anniversary update makes it very difficult (read impossible for average users) to disable Cortana.
  • Windows 10 violates the basic networking principles: it ignores the hosts files, the DNS protocol and firewall rules and sends telemetry data regardless."

You have no control, over crucial features. (Vote: True/Agreed... Windows 7 was the last very easy version of Windows to navigate as a desktop OS, and they revamped all the Windows to the point just enabling the "This PC, etc." "desktop icons is a PITA to find )

Windows 10 has builds such as 1511, 1607, and now the Creator's update. For all intents and purposes these are like brand-new releases of the OS with whatever updates, feature fixes, and Service Packs slip-streamed into it. (Vote: Windows 10... get a clean-build almost annually)

You CAN opt-out or even hide updates, but what you cannot do is pick and choose as granularity as before. The updater really does NOT give you the same level of control of selecting specifically which ones you get... Instead, it just updates. Here is the hide utility: https://support.microsoft.com/en-us...driver-update-from-reinstalling-in-windows-10. That said, many users were NOT up-to-date, and they fixed that. (Vote: toss-up)

Safemode becomes impossible... (Vote: Toss-up because the new preboot environment is better - you can even "Reset this PC" with the downside that virtually nobody prepared it. They should really add a way to interrupt the boot process.)

Cannot disable Cortana... (Vote: Toss-up because some folks like it, and you actually can disable it if i you are a power-user via the Local Group Policy Editor under Computer Configureation > Admin Templates > Windows Components > Search > Allow Cortana = Disabled. Either way you can hide the annoying search bar on the start bar.)

Violates Network Principles (Vote: False, I don't know about telemetry data, but it gives you mechanisms to limit this. That said, overall the DNS, Host Files, all just work, and WiFi is a bit more intelligent in picking printers for your network etc.. I hand this one to Windows 10)

************

Bottom Line: Windows 7, 8.1 or 10 are all just fine with me. I do not like the new ones better... It has gotten to the point I just don't care what version of Windows I run so long as it is stable, reasonably secure, and runs my desired applications. Basically, I do NOT care about the OS but rather care about what I can do with it.
 
Just got a call back from a client that is going thru homegroup hell.

Why they did this I do not know but they started a home group between their two computers at work. As soon as they rebooted the accounting computer they lost all network discovery. Thus, Their printers and such were gone. They called me and I remoted into the accounting computer and went to homegroups and removed them from the home group. Then rebooted it. It came up and looked fine. No issues. However, They called the next day and had the same issue. So, I logged in and saw that even though network discovery was on they could not find any printers and no resources were available except the other computer in the homegroup. Ok, So I went in and turned off the homegroup services and rebooted. Everything once again came back fine. Next day - new phone call - same issue. When I looked at the homegroup settings it shows the yellow exclamation point that no homegroups could be found and they were not connected to any homegroups. Same stupid issue - cannot discover any network resources. BUT - Could access the other computer in its homegroup.

Today I remoted into the other computer and told it to remove itself from the homegroup. Did a complete shutdown and restart and then went back to the accounting computer and did a full shutdown and had them turn it on - problem didnt come back. Hopefully this fixes it.

Evidently like everything else in Windersland once you join something you are locked into it somehow.

**** In the link to the website I had a bit of a laugh as one comment said that you better get away from winders10 and just go buy a chromebook. Humm. Chromebook=google. Good luck with that. :)
 
**** In the link to the website I had a bit of a laugh as one comment said that you better get away from winders10 and just go buy a chromebook. Humm. Chromebook=google. Good luck with that. :)

Honestly, if the client is residential and has minimal needs, that is exactly what I would recommend instead--a Chromebook.
 
Honestly, if the client is residential and has minimal needs, that is exactly what I would recommend instead--a Chromebook.

My biggest issue with Chromebooks is that they only have a 5 year lifespan, I don't think I own a computer that's younger than 5.
 
The only way I would ever buy a Chromebook is to put linux on it. I trust google about as much as M$.

I looked into that once, but it seems like putting a full linux distro on there isn't as simple as you would think.
 
While overall I find Windows 10 a good, or at least decent experience, I do find it to be flawed in many ways mostly in the lack of user control. It has made the job of a technician more difficult comparative to Windows 7, hard to compare to 8 and 8.1 as those were mostly steered clear of during their short life, but not so much so that it is truly a pain to work with. My greatest complain would be the lack of a reliable means of booting to Safe Mode w/ a Windows boot media or booting into a working windows. My view is Microsoft has made some mistakes and the question is will they continue down the path the lead to these mistakes or will they right the ship onto a better more user rights path.
 
I find Windows 10 rather amusing and with the amount of hidden content that we've all agreed to let MSoft use against us its not surprising people come out with different pieces of software to really shut down how the system works. I've been using ShutUp10 since the beginning and as for everything else, booting to safe mode in Windows 10 isn't rocket science once you know how to do it easily in less than a few steps but hising that option for the average user is just useless.
 
Back
Top