Stumped on pc repair.

Avidist

New Member
Reaction score
0
I cannot figure out what is going on with my PC. I built it in 2008.
Parts:
Asus p5q Mobo
Intel core 2 duo e6850
nvidia geforce 9600 gt
hitachi 160gb sata hd
500 watt PSU
Running windows vista ultimate

I have a little home repair computer business. I have business cards that I hand out and just operate by word of mouth. I've used this machine as basically my personal computer, AND my test machine for swapping parts, so it's definitely had more wear than just a desktop computer. I've probably taken it apart and put it back 50 times since I bought it, if not more. I've been super swamped lately and I feel like my brain is fried. A customers laptop motherboard went bad, so they asked me to get the data off of their hard drive and onto some dvd's. No problem right? Well, I hook their laptop harddrive into the second sata slot on my motherboard, and boot my pc. Well, for some reason it booted straight to his harddrive. Normally when I hook other harddrives up in the secondary slot it still boots to mine. So I turn it off, disconnect his harddrive altogether. When I boot up again, my monitor stays in standby mode. I have an older "office" Dell monitor, one of their older flatscreens. The light was staying orange as when the computer is in sleep mode, or standby. I fooled with it for a bit, and nothing worked, so I did a complete disassembled of the computer, and then reassembled it, just to double check all the connections. This time it booted it fine (only my hard drive hooked up). I decided to use an external method and my netbook to get the data from his hard drive to avoid any more problems with mine.
The next time I go to use the machine, it boots up fine. I did some normal stuff, redeemed a Steam Wallet Code, and started downloading Counter-Strike: Global Offensive. It was something like a 5gb file so I turned the monitor off and checked back about an hour later. I went to turn the monitor on, and it's in standby. Restart the machine, standby. 3 days of messing with stuff later, standby.

TL;DR - PC turns on, all parts run, monitor stays in Standby

This is what I've done so far (I have nothing but essential parts in the machine):
Tried different hard drives, sata and ide. No change.
Tried pulling the ram and trying one stick at a time. No change.
Tried new ram all together. No change.
Reset CMOS. No change.
Complete reassembly. No change.
Different Graphics cards. No change.
New VGA/DVI Converter. No change.
Monitor is fine, tried it on my netbook.
I don't have another 20+4 pin PSU, so I tried my PSU in an old Dell with a Pentium 4, and that machine booted up fine.

Like I said above, the computer turns on fine, all the parts power up including my 4 LED fans, the fan and lights on the cpu, the PSU lights and fan, the harddrive spins, the GPU fan spins, the motherboard indicator light turns on. I even booted up for a couple seconds without the cpu fan on and the cpu gets warm just as it should (though I just left it on for under 10 seconds.) I cannot seem to figure out the problem here.
Could the motherboard be bad, even though all the other parts seem to be getting power? I've never had a single problem with my mobo, even with the abuse I've put it through. What else could I try short of buying all new parts and just swapping things out one at a time? I'm pretty strapped for cash so I'm trying to do this as inexpensive as possible. I just feel like I'm missing something, which is why I've come here.
The only thing I can think is maybe some small part on the motherboard has gone bad that's not affecting anything else, or my PSU is screwed up and can't put out enough power for my machine, but works fine on the Dell that's only a 20 pin connection. I don't know.

ANY HELP is GREATLY appreciated.
-Jacob
 
I posted it in another forum, but after I logged in again to check for replies, it said I couldn't access the page. I then looked and it didn't even show up under "Threads started by Avidist". So I posted it in this forum figuring that it got taken down or somehow I posted it there without proper permissions.
 
I don't see your introduction post...did you bother to read the forum rules prior to posting?
 
based on the information sounds like motherboard to me, not much else it could be given the steps you took....unless you managed to kill the cpu via overclocking
 
My apologies on not reading the rules thoroughly. I skimmed over them. But, as you can read about in my newly posted introduction, I'm not an End-User.

ComputerRepairTech - Yeah, I was starting to wonder the same thing. I never really noticed it before, but I never installed the speaker to my motherboard. I'm going out to get a new speaker and see what the BEEP codes tell me, although they probably will point to the motherboard by not beeping at all, hah. The CPU should be fine. I played with OC'ing when I first got it but realized I'd rather have the extended life than more power right then, plus I didn't really need the power. It was OC'd for a total of about 15 minutes 4 years ago so I don't think that's the problem.
 
Last edited:
My apologies on not reading the rules thoroughly. I skimmed over them. But, as you can read about in my newly posted introduction, I'm not an End-User.

ComputerRepairTech - Yeah, I was starting to wonder the same thing. I never really noticed it before, but I never installed the speaker to my motherboard. I'm going out to get a new speaker and see what the BEEP codes tell me, although they probably will point to the motherboard by not beeping at all, hah. The CPU should be fine. I played with OC'ing when I first got it but realized I'd rather have the extended life than more power right then, plus I didn't really need the power. It was OC'd for a total of about 15 minutes 4 years ago so I don't think that's the problem.

lol, my Q6600 and Abit IP35 Pro was at stock for about 15 minutes 4 years ago! what a coincidence :cool:
 
Great minds think alike (and prefer operating life over extra power I suppose : P)!

Well, I bought a different motherboard today and using my parts it booted fine. I just don't get why my motherboard went bad or what's wrong with it. I have to return this new motherboard regardless because of the way my chassis is made. The pci slot for the gpu is at the top, and with my case it doesn't allow me to plug in the DVI/VGA converter, there just isn't enough room the way it's shaped.

If it had happened the first time and never worked again, I would just accept that the motherboard went bad. But in ALL my years of experience, when a board goes bad it goes bad for good. It usually doesn't go bad and then work again, and then go bad for good...

I guess there's a first time for everything.
 
Great minds think alike (and prefer operating life over extra power I suppose : P)!

Well, I bought a different motherboard today and using my parts it booted fine. I just don't get why my motherboard went bad or what's wrong with it. I have to return this new motherboard regardless because of the way my chassis is made. The pci slot for the gpu is at the top, and with my case it doesn't allow me to plug in the DVI/VGA converter, there just isn't enough room the way it's shaped.

If it had happened the first time and never worked again, I would just accept that the motherboard went bad. But in ALL my years of experience, when a board goes bad it goes bad for good. It usually doesn't go bad and then work again, and then go bad for good...

I guess there's a first time for everything.

Guess I ain't a great mind then, cause i was sayin its been Overclocked for 4 years and still runnin just fine. Only ran at stock speeds for about 15 minutes, maybe a half hour total its entire life... :cool:
OC'ing will drop approx ~2 years off the life of your processor. and since the life of an average processor is more than the life of every other component in the system (especially the board), I always go extra power! Cause from where I'm sittin, unless you do something majorly wrong, it doesn't hurt anything. But thats me. :D

Anyway, intermitten board failures happen all the time, and there is rarely a good reason. They can be a PITA to find and fix sometimes! Get use to em though, if your in this business long, you'll see a ton...
 
My reply was going to go something like this, but I am a jerk...


I cannot figure out what is going on with my PC. I built it in 2008.
Parts:
Asus p5q Mobo
Intel core 2 duo e6850
nvidia geforce 9600 gt
hitachi 160gb sata hd
500 watt PSU
Running windows vista ultimate

I have a little home repair computer business. I have business cards that I hand out and just operate by word of mouth. <== Do you advertise on Craigslist?

I've probably taken it apart and put it back 50 times since I bought it, if not more. <== Yeah... I wouldn't recommend taking it apart and putting it back together 50 times because the connectors, slots, pins, etc are going to fatigue.

A customers laptop motherboard went bad, so they asked me to get the data off of their hard drive and onto some dvd's. No problem right? <== No problem when it is your time. Go ahead and put their data on DVDs, or CDs, or even floppy disks if you want.

Well, I hook their laptop harddrive into the second sata slot on my motherboard, and boot my pc. Well, for some reason it booted straight to his harddrive. <== Wow, you mean it doesn't know which slot to boot. Hum... imagine that boot sequence in the BIOS might come into play here.


When I boot up again, my monitor stays in standby mode. I have an older "office" Dell monitor, one of their older flatscreens. The light was staying orange as when the computer is in sleep mode, or standby. <== Yeah, the wheel is turning but the hamster is dead and nobody is home right?


I fooled with it for a bit, and nothing worked, so I did a complete disassembled of the computer, and then reassembled it, just to double check all the connections. <== Yeah, the 51st time you reassemble it, you are bound to do a better job at double-checking the connections.


3 days of messing with stuff later, standby. <== Yup... still broken.

TL;DR - PC turns on, all parts run, monitor stays in Standby <==Right tell us something we don't know.



Tried different hard drives, sata and ide. No change. <== Yeah, the system won't POST, so you tried different drives and that didn't work? Did you waste your time trying different keyboards an seeing if it mattered what CDs you put in the drive?


Tried pulling the ram and trying one stick at a time. No change.
Tried new ram all together. No change.
Reset CMOS. No change.
Complete reassembly. No change. <==52nd time you took it apart and put it back together!!! Damn there must be a loose connection in here somewhere!
Different Graphics cards. No change.
New VGA/DVI Converter. No change.
Monitor is fine, tried it on my netbook.
I don't have another 20+4 pin PSU, so I tried my PSU in an old Dell with a Pentium 4, and that machine booted up fine.

Like I said above, the computer turns on fine, all the parts power up including my 4 LED fans, the fan and lights on the cpu, the PSU lights and fan, the harddrive spins, the GPU fan spins, the motherboard indicator light turns on. I even booted up for a couple seconds without the cpu fan on and the cpu gets warm just as it should (though I just left it on for under 10 seconds.) I cannot seem to figure out the problem here. <== Nope, you haven't figured it out yet.

Could the motherboard be bad, even though all the other parts seem to be getting power? <==Maybe this would be a good place to look.


I've never had a single problem with my mobo <==Are you sure *HINT*

What else could I try short of buying all new parts and just swapping things out one at a time? <==You could try a troubleshooting methodology that leads you to a conclusion of what is wrong, and you could replace the one part that is actually bad... Maybe the part you never had a single problem with.

I'm pretty strapped for cash so I'm trying to do this as inexpensive as possible. <== Yeah, we all understand being strapped for cash.


I just feel like I'm missing something, which is why I've come here.
The only thing I can think is maybe some small part on the motherboard has gone bad that's not affecting anything else <== Yeah or that bad part might be affecting the board causing it not to POST, causing the video card to not put any signal on the screen... causing your "Standby Issue"...

-Jacob


^^ Of course, I would have only said all that if I was being a complete jerk talking to someone who was asking for help on his personal computer...
 
Last edited:
Back
Top