Windows 11 23H2 coming this fall as a small enablement package

Let's not forgot about Dev Drive and Dev Home...

Microsoft Defender capability named "performance mode" for developers on Windows 11, tuned to reduce the impact of antivirus scans when analyzing files stored on Dev Drives.

Introduced at this year's Microsoft Build conference, Dev Drive is a new type of Windows 11 storage volume using the Resilient File System (ReFS) available in public preview and offers developers enhanced performance and resiliency against data corruption.

Um... Okay, so we HAVE heard of ReFS, but how exactly is this new other than the fact nobody uses it. "A trusted Dev Drive means that the developer using the volume has high confidence in the security of the content stored there"

Great, now we will see malware flag entire volumes as Dev Drives and presto Anti Virus will be good with it!
 
ReFS is Microsoft's version of ZFS. It's less a filesystem and more what happens when you decide to make a SQL database your filesystem. It does have value, particularly in situations where you need snapshots and indexing. Development workloads would benefit from this certainly... but it still makes little sense when you should be working out of a code repository that does all that for you.

Defender DOES go ape though if development is happening within its purview. And the only real way to fix that is to dell Defender to ignore a given folder. This is a security problem, so it seems Microsoft has decided to force development into the obscure new filesystem that is harder to access via automation tools so they can flag the entire volume to Defender to relax... the performance gains are from Defender taking a seat, not the file system. ReFS itself is a memory hog relative to NTFS unless you have an Exchange message store or bunch of SQL databases on it.

Forcing this feature to ReFS volumes means exactly what you suggested cannot happen. You cannot convert NTFS to ReFS and back again. And you cannot boot to ReFS. I see little opportunity here for malware to abuse this configuration, as you'd have to be using such a system for it to be abused. Most machines have a single drive, those will by necessity be NTFS and this feature will not be available.

In related news, Microsoft quietly removed some 8th generation Xeons from the Windows 11 compatibility list with this feature release. https://www.xda-developers.com/microsoft-removes-intel-cpus-windows-11-support/

This sets an interesting precedent... one that Microsoft has yet to actually adhere to, and yet should! If each annual feature release drops the old stuff that isn't OK anymore, the machines that are dropped have 1 year of support left to plan replacement. This evolutionary pressure would keep Windows 11 "current", as well as the platforms they live on. It would prevent the need for a Windows 12, because that was the mistake that was made with Windows 10. Yet... I don't think that's what's happening here. I'm pretty sure MS just updated a list and forgot to copy / paste a few items.
 
Interesting, as I had thought Microsoft had made the decision to dump ReFS entirely.
Nope! But unless you're working in the niche places where it actually makes sense to use it... I can see how you'd think that way.

It's not a filesystem that has any place on a desktop! Anyone that's used btrfs or ZFS has used similar tech, and knows those things live on NAS / SAN devices for a reason. ReFS is very much the same, you need a Microsoft based storage server solution to use it effectively.

You CAN use it on the desktop, but again you cannot boot to an ReFS volume. So you'd need a 2nd drive or at least 2nd partition deployed and formatted to use it with an NTFS volume doing the C drive work as normal.

MS is trying to add value to a filesystem here that doesn't make a ton of sense other than "it's not NTFS", which I can sort of see the logic in this circumstance... but yikes it's weak. I'll have to check into this more later, perhaps I'm missing something.
 
Back
Top