CompTIA's Certification Changes

xacked

New Member
Reaction score
0
So I've got my college finals coming up next week and I just read this:

Effective January 1, 2011, all new CompTIA A+, CompTIA Network+ or CompTIA Security+ certifications will be valid for three years from the date the candidate is certified. After three years, the certification must be renewed. This can be done by passing the most current exam for a respective certification or by participating in CompTIA’s upcoming new continuing education program, which will allow individuals to keep their skills current and their certification up to date without retesting.

Source:
http://www.comptia.org/certifications/listed/renewal/letter.aspx

I was also reading through their renewal policy which I found pretty absurd...their Continuing Education sets the bar high (see their unit requirements), and it also charges $75 every 3 years for the A+ and DOUBLE that for Network+ and Security+.. does this smell of corporate greed? Given the inherent high price of the test they are asking a lot from people.

I've got my A+, but this seems to be forcing my hand to get my Network+ ASAP, I have a friend doing the same. I bet other techs who have been on the fence are now being forced to opt in for legacy, or out with the CE requirement. The economy is doing splendidly and I'm sure people want to pony up the annual 25 as well for this...

If you want my honest opinion, here's my pro/con list:

Pros:
It's an industry certification and is a good resume booster.
It encourages you to learn more and understand computer/IT/security fundamentals.

Cons:
It's expensive
It's getting more expensive after this year.
The test isn't representative of real-world scenarios, it's simply knowledge-based questions, things you'd have learned if you grew up around computers, read pc magazines, or had any job experience.
It won't help you that much with your job (in my opinion).

I spent about 40 hours studying for it and got an 830. I was 17 at the time.

Now I gotta study for college finals, fly home, cram for the test, take it, then go on a trip to visit relatives in Asia. My point isn't as much a complaint as the inconvenience this deadline has created.

Happy Holidays folks!
 
They are getting greedy.

Thats the only explanation for it. They, like everyone else, want to make more money.

I don't plan to ever get my A+ because most of the people I have met with A+'s are complete morons. Not to offend anyone but the people I have met with just an A+ could not fix the time on a VCR.
 
After over 25 years in the industry, I looked into doing the CompTIA stuff a couple of years ago when I started my business. Now call me cynical but my impression was that they were developing a very nice business model for themselves - i.e. they were achieving a critical mass in terms of the number of people obtaining their qualifications and were gaining a level of recognition within the industry that reinforced the value of their qualifications, something that Microsoft, Cisco and all the other big players have been doing for a while with their various certifications.

But having looked at the CompTIA course/exam contents I felt that it wasn't that up-to-date and only seemed to cover the basics, I felt it was more targeted at those that were either new into the industry or lacking in real world industry experience. For the money, I couldn't see the benefit to me as an individual, though I have no doubt there is benefit to my business from gaining the ability to use the CompTIA 'stamp' on my advertising, web site etc as I'm sure it builds confidence and credibility with prospective customers.

Don't get me wrong, I have nothing against industry certification but something in me objects to paying quite significant sums of money for what amounts to a 'rubber stamp' simply because others have it - especially when the certifying organisation wants to turn its qualified people/organisations into a nice little recurring revenue stream for themselves.
 
On top of the pro/cons that you have listed which is somewhat acurate. But, maybe you need to add another list under it and call it "Possibilities"

Possibilities

I start my computer business and it does not do well and I have to get an actual job somewhere with a company that requires certifications

I am going to attempt to get a job and compete against others that have gotten their certifications

YOur last line says "I gotta study for college finals" so apparently you have decided that college is important in your furture plans. Is it needed to run a computer business? I don't think so. Will it help your computer business? I doubt it. But, you are going to study and take the finals correct?

My point is anything that can enhance your value (career) is worth it. Unfortunetely Comptia has turned up the time to make it financially the time to take it.

p.s. Congrats on college and the finals I actually do think that is important also....
 
They are getting greedy.

Thats the only explanation for it. They, like everyone else, want to make more money.

I don't plan to ever get my A+ because most of the people I have met with A+'s are complete morons. Not to offend anyone but the people I have met with just an A+ could not fix the time on a VCR.

Are you saying that taking the A+ actually makes you dumber? That would explain a lot over the past 9 years since I've been certified...... :D
 
Are you saying that taking the A+ actually makes you dumber? That would explain a lot over the past 9 years since I've been certified...... :D

No, I would not say it makes you dumber. Its just I think the majority of people that take it where dumb to begin with. Current company exuded of course, lol. :D
 
I agree with re-certification for this industry as a lot of aspects change, in theory. That's if the certifications actually prove anything, which A+ obviously doesn't, so I'm not really bothered by the changes either way. I think they were greedy before, for charging for a pointless product.
 
On top of the pro/cons that you have listed which is somewhat acurate. But, maybe you need to add another list under it and call it "Possibilities"

Possibilities

I start my computer business and it does not do well and I have to get an actual job somewhere with a company that requires certifications

I am going to attempt to get a job and compete against others that have gotten their certifications

YOur last line says "I gotta study for college finals" so apparently you have decided that college is important in your furture plans. Is it needed to run a computer business? I don't think so. Will it help your computer business? I doubt it. But, you are going to study and take the finals correct?

My point is anything that can enhance your value (career) is worth it. Unfortunetely Comptia has turned up the time to make it financially the time to take it.

p.s. Congrats on college and the finals I actually do think that is important also....

Haha, thanks :), you make great points about the "possibilities" section. College is priority right now for me, I'm working my way through reviewing for my chemistry and psychology classes, I won't even start Network + studying until after I take my last final.

I completely agree with you, even if I ever end up opening a computer business (which isn't in my plans) it wouldn't help me. But anything to make future employers happy with my resume I guess.
 
I have an A+ cert that I got back in high school, I kind of figured CompTIA would go this route of having them expire :rolleyes:

It doesn't hurt to have an A+ cert, but I can't see any potential serious employer requiring it. Maybe very entry level type stuff.
 
It doesn't hurt to have an A+ cert, but I can't see any potential serious employer requiring it. Maybe very entry level type stuff.

Actually alot of that depends on where you live. The OP actually has San Diego as his place and there is quite a few govt jobs in that area so I can see companies that will require it.

I am in the D.C. area and it's the same here. Actually had a lady come in the other day (3rd time) for A+ test. She works a govt help desk contract. Companies that do govt contracting "need" the certs for billing rates..So A+, Security+, etc all carry alot of weight.
 
You're currently in college? A college degree will get you way farther than any of the tech certifications; I wouldn't even bother with certifications.

I definitely agree, the certs are just at the moment a hobby.
 
Back
Top